How Do Congressional Investigations Work?

Congressional committees investigate government and corporate wrongdoing using tools like subpoenas, hearings and sworn testimony. Those investigations rarely lead to jail time, but they expose the truth and drive reform, so whether Congress uses them is a choice voters can hold it accountable for.

We’re leading the movement to make government more accountable to the people

What is a congressional investigation?

A congressional investigation is a formal inquiry by Congress, usually run by one of its committees, into a problem, an event, or the conduct of a person or institution. Targets range from a federal agency allegedly misspending money, to a company accused of misleading the public, to a senior official suspected of abusing power.

The word “investigation” doesn’t appear in the Constitution. The Supreme Court has made clear the power comes with Congress’s job of writing laws, funding the government, and checking the executive branch. The power has limits. An investigation has to serve a legitimate legislative purpose, and Congress can’t act as a court or expose people’s private lives just to embarrass them.

Who runs congressional investigations?

Committees do nearly all of the work. Every standing committee in Congress is required by law to keep “continuous watchfulness” over the agencies it oversees, so investigating is part of the job, not an optional extra. Committees generally stay within their own policy areas, but a few have authority across the whole federal government (more on those below). For the biggest scandals, Congress sometimes creates a temporary select committee devoted to one issue, like the Senate Watergate Committee, the Iran-Contra investigation, or the House Select Committee on January 6th.

The majority party controls each committee. That matters enormously. The committee chair decides what gets investigated, who gets subpoenaed, and whether a hearing happens at all. A chair who refuses to act can effectively shield an agency or official from scrutiny.

The minority party usually can’t call hearings or issue subpoenas on its own 1. Minority members can still write letters, request information, hold press conferences, and work with whistleblowers. Whether agencies must answer those requests is contested. During the first Trump administration, the Justice Department argued agencies don’t have to respond to individual members who aren’t committee chairs. Senate Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley, a Republican, called that position “nonsense.” 2

1 “Despite Reduced Investigative Authority, Congressional Democrats Ramp up Trump Administration Oversight,” King & Spalding News and Insights, available at https://www.kslaw.com/news-and-insights/despite-reduced-investigative-authority-congressional-democrats-ramp-up-trump-administration-oversight

2 Carl Levin and Elise J. Bean, Defining Congressional Oversight and Measuring its Effectiveness, 64 Wayne L. Rev. 1, 16 (2018).

Where do congressional investigations come from?

Big public investigations rarely start from scratch. They usually build on information that has been piling up:

  • Watchdog reports: The Government Accountability Office (GAO), Congress’s nonpartisan investigative arm, and the more than 70 Inspectors General inside federal agencies are supposed to monitor and flag waste, fraud, and abuse. Inspectors General are legally required to forward serious findings to Congress.
  • Whistleblowers: Federal employees have a legally protected right to talk to Congress, even if their agency tells them not to. Several committees, including House Oversight, Senate Finance, and Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, run dedicated whistleblower intake channels. In 2019, a whistleblower complaint about President Trump’s call with Ukraine’s president led directly to a House impeachment inquiry.
  • News reports and constituent complaints: A major news story or a pattern of complaints from voters can push a committee to act.

The 2014 Veterans Affairs scandal shows how this works. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) had warned in 2000, 2004, and 2013 that VA wait-time data was unreliable. 3 When CNN reported that veterans had died waiting for care, Congress already had years of documentation. Committees held emergency hearings, subpoenaed VA officials, and passed bipartisan reform legislation within months.

3 Kenneth Lowande, Who Polices the Administrative State? 112 American Political Science Review 874 (2018).

What tools can Congress use to investigate?

Committees have a set of tools that escalate from polite requests to legal compulsion:

  • Letters and document requests: Most investigations start with a letter asking for information. Many agencies and companies comply voluntarily, at least in part. Members of Congress send tens of thousands of these letters every year. 4
  • Subpoenas: If a request is refused, a committee can issue a subpoena. This is a legally binding order to hand over documents or show up and testify. 5 Each committee’s rules set who can issue one. In many House committees the chair can do it alone, while some Senate committees require a vote or the minority’s agreement.
  • Records review: Committee investigators, often lawyers, comb through emails, financial records, contracts, and internal memos. Much of the real work happens here, out of public view.
  • Depositions and interviews: Staff often question witnesses privately before any public hearing. Depositions are taken under oath and transcribed.
  • Public hearings: Witnesses testify before the committee, usually under oath, and members question them on the record.
  • Reports and referrals: Investigations typically end with a written report of findings and recommendations. If a committee finds evidence of a possible crime, it can formally refer the matter to the Justice Department.

4 Lowande, supra note 3.

5 Levin and Bean, supra note 2.

What happens if someone ignores a congressional subpoena?

Defying a congressional subpoena can be a crime 6, but enforcement is slow and often political. Congress has three main options.

Criminal contempt: The committee and then the full House or Senate vote to hold the person in contempt of Congress. The case goes to the Justice Department, which decides whether to prosecute. Contempt of Congress is a federal misdemeanor punishable by up to a year in jail. It does happen: former Trump advisers Steve Bannon and Peter Navarro were each convicted and served four months in federal prison in 2024. But the Justice Department is part of the executive branch. Since the mid-1980s, it has often declined to prosecute officials who defied Congress on the president’s instructions.

Civil enforcement: Congress can sue in federal court and ask a judge to order compliance. This avoids relying on the Justice Department, but court cases can take months or years. By the time a judge rules, the political moment may have passed, the official may have left, or a new Congress may have taken over and dropped the matter.

Inherent contempt: In theory, Congress can enforce its own subpoenas by having its Sergeant at Arms detain the person, or by imposing fines. It hasn’t used this power since 1935.

Subpoenas carry real weight for private citizens and former officials, but can be difficult to enforce against a sitting administration determined to resist. 

During President Trump’s first term in office, his administration repeatedly refused to comply with congressional subpoenas. During his second term, the Department of Justice’s Office of Legal Counsel has issued an opinion attempting to invoke “executive privilege” to block congressional subpoenas of private individuals the administration claims has advised it.

6  Id.

What happens if someone lies to Congress?

Lying to Congress is a federal crime, under oath or not. Witnesses under oath can be charged with perjury. Separately, knowingly making false statements to Congress, including in written answers and informal interviews, is a felony that can carry up to five years in prison. Trump adviser Roger Stone, for example, was convicted in 2019 of lying to the House Intelligence Committee. Because of that risk, sworn testimony puts real pressure on witnesses. Many would rather decline to answer, or invoke their Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination, than risk a false statement on the record.

Why do congressional investigations matter if they rarely send anyone to jail?

Most investigations don’t end in criminal charges. Their power comes from elsewhere:

  • Publicity: Hearings put information in front of the press and the public. Televised testimony can shift public opinion in a way a long report never will. The nationally televised Watergate hearings changed how Americans saw the Nixon administration well before he resigned.
  • Testimony under oath: Putting someone under oath and on the record locks in their story. Later contradictions can become legal problems, and the testimony becomes part of the permanent public record.
  • Uncovering documents: Subpoenaed records often reveal facts that would otherwise stay hidden, and they can fuel news coverage, lawsuits, and prosecutions.
  • Changing behavior: The threat of scrutiny alone can push agencies and companies to fix problems or hand over information voluntarily.
  • Driving new laws: Many major reforms began as investigations. Watergate led to the Ethics in Government Act and to 1974 campaign finance reforms that created the Federal Election Commission. The 9/11 Commission’s findings led to the Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004, which created the Director of National Intelligence.

The most effective investigations pair the public moment with months of document review and staff work behind the scenes.

Which congressional committees matter most for holding the government accountable?

Several committees can investigate within their own areas, but three groups do the main work on corruption, abuse of power, and government accountability:

House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform and Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs: Congress’s main investigative committees, able to examine nearly any part of the federal government. The Senate committee also includes the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations.

House and Senate Judiciary Committees: Oversee the Justice Department, the FBI, and the federal courts. The House Judiciary Committee also handles impeachment.

House Ways and Means and Senate Finance Committees: The tax-writing committees, which oversee the Treasury Department and the IRS. They can legally obtain any individual’s tax returns.

Why should Americans pay attention to congressional investigations?

Investigations are one of the main ways the public learns what its government is actually doing. When Congress investigates, builds a factual record, and acts on what it finds, the results can last for decades, as the post-Watergate reforms and the post-financial-crisis rules did. 7

When it doesn’t, power shifts quietly toward the executive branch, and problems surface only after real harm is done. Whether Congress uses these tools isn’t automatic. It’s a choice, and voters can hold members accountable for it.

7  Levin Center, Portraits in Oversight: Financial Crisis: Taking on the Big Banks, available at https://levin-center.org/what-is-oversight/portraits/financial-crisis/

How We Hold Congress Accountable

Join the movement to call on Congress to investigate abuse of power and corruption by the Trump administration. Together, we can make sure there are consequences for corruption. Read more about our Campaign for Accountability here.

Recommended Reading

Can the President Pardon Anyone?
Mar 31 2026

How Presidential Pardons Should Work, and How They Can Be Abused

Learn more
What is Due Process?
May 29 2025

Constitutional rights aren’t privileges for the favored. They’re limits on government power. The moment we allow exceptions, we risk turning those exceptions into the rule.

Learn more
Can Trump Serve a Third Term?
Apr 8 2025

President Donald Trump recently suggested he is considering ways to serve a third term, stating, “I’m not joking.”

Learn more
How Big Money Took Over Politics
Apr 7 2025

Nearly $13 billion more is being spent on elections today than in 1998. This surge in election spending has ultimately led to politicians and government listening more to special interests and the wealthy few, at the expense of everyday Americans.

Learn more
The Important Role of the Courts as a Check on Power
Mar 13 2025

Our judicial system plays an important but often overlooked role in the successful balance of power.

Learn more
What exactly is an Executive Order?
Mar 3 2025

The president isn’t a king, and executive orders aren’t absolute. Our Constitution has a set of checks and balances to keep any one branch from becoming too powerful.

Learn more
Is America Becoming a Kleptocracy?
Feb 15 2025

This question has become particularly pressing since the United States was recently classified as a backsliding democracy for the first time in its history.

Learn more
What do inspectors general do?
Feb 10 2025

When the government falls short of serving the public’s interests, inspectors general (IGs) are there to act as safeguards against corruption, mismanagement, and inefficiency.

Learn more