How our Voting System Blocks Voters from Embracing New Voices
The way that most Americans vote is flawed, but thankfully there’s a better system that leads to better outcomes and better representation that’s catching on in cities and states all across the country. It’s called Ranked Choice Voting.
What’s wrong with our current system?
Most Americans vote under a “first-past-the-post” electoral system, meaning that the candidate with the highest number of votes wins.
It sounds simple and makes sense at face-value, but there are a number of issues with this approach, including:
- No majority required to win. For example, in a three-candidate race, a candidate with 35% of the votes can win, while the other candidates have 30% and 25%, respectively. Not exactly a mandate for governing ALL people.
- Underrepresentation of minority views: First-past-the-post tend to favor larger political parties because the ability to win seats with just a plurality of votes means that small parties and independent candidates are viewed as “spoilers,” and have difficulty building enough support to win more votes than the major parties. This can marginalize smaller parties and minority viewpoints, leading to a less diverse representation in the legislature.
- Polarization and divisiveness: First-past-the-post voting can contribute to political polarization and divisiveness by promoting a “winner-takes-all” mentality and discouraging candidates from appealing to as wide of a voter base as possible. When all candidates need to win is to get more votes than anyone else, they’re incentivized to appeal to their base and try to discourage anyone else from voting.
In fact, under our current election system the public’s trust in government has reached near record lows because many people feel that the system fails to address their needs and that their voices are neither heard nor adequately represented.
Ranked Choice Voting: A Better Way to Vote
Ranked Choice Voting (RCV), also known as instant-runoff voting, is a super simple tweak to our electoral system that leads to profound positive effects.
In RCV elections, you rank your candidates from favorite to least favorite, and if your top choice doesn’t have enough support, your vote can still count toward your next choice, giving you the freedom to vote for your favorite candidate without fear of wasting your vote.
The benefits of RCV
With Ranked Choice Voting, the benefits over winner-take-all systems are clear and numerous:
- Results in majority, consensus winners
- Eliminates spoiler candidates and voting for the “lesser of two evils.”
- Saves tax dollars by avoiding runoff elections
- Promotes cleaner campaigns with less mud-slinging since candidates have to appeal to ALL voters
- Improves opportunities for Independent and third-party candidates
How RCV works
In a Ranked Choice Voting election, voters have the option to rank candidates in order of choice – first choice, second choice, and so on. If a candidate wins a majority of first-choice votes, they win – just like today.
But if nobody receives a majority of first choices, the candidate with the fewest votes is eliminated. The voters who ranked that candidate first then have their vote instantly go to their second choice. This process, which is called instant runoff, continues until there is a majority winner.
Voters love RCV
Ranked Choice Voting has been implemented in dozens of cities and states across the country and voters love it:
- In Alaska, 85% said RCV is simple and easy-to-understand.
- In Maine, 61% of voters supported keeping or expanding RCV.
- In New York City, 95% of voters found their ballot simple to complete and 77% supported using RCV in future local elections.
- In Boulder, CO, 86% of voters said it was easy and 77% were satisfied with their voting experience.
We can go on and on, but everywhere it’s been tried, RCV has been proven a popular success.
How do we get more cities and states to adopt Ranked Choice Voting?
If we want better representation and better outcomes, we know we can’t count on our broken Congress to make improvements to our electoral system to give voters better representation.
Since 2012, we’ve scored 197 wins all across the country, passing structural reform policies like RCV to fix our broken political system. See our wins »
Instead, we follow a proven strategy of bypassing Congress to pass structural reforms like Ranked Choice Voting at the local and state level.
But we can’t do it alone.
You Can Make A Difference
Keep Learning
Proportional Representation, Explained
Sep 10 2024
Is proportional representation the answer to America’s broken political system?
What’s driving political polarization and how can we solve it?
Aug 27 2024
What if our political system and the way we vote is contributing to the problem?
Why do we call America a democracy?
Mar 11 2024
And why do some insist it isn’t?
Why Aren't There More Political Parties in the U.S.?
Feb 29 2024
Americans want more options, but our election system pushes us toward a duopoly.
Are the Presidential Primaries Rigged?
Feb 15 2024
Sadly, everything the Biden and Trump campaigns did to alter the primaries was entirely legal.
The Oregon Trail: How We Pioneer A Path to Ranked Choice Voting
Jul 28 2023
Oregon could become the largest state in the country to utilize RCV for state and federal elections.
The solution to Georgia's expensive and unnecessary Senate runoff
Dec 12 2022
If Georgia had Instant Runoff Voting (IRV), the recent runoff election for the U.S. Senate would not have been necessary.
Alaska's New Election System Isn't Wild. It's A Model For The Future.
Jun 30 2022
The recent first-of-its-kind special primary election to fill Alaska’s at-large seat in the U.S. House of Representatives was a success for democracy.
What Is The “Spoiler Effect” And How Do We Solve It?
May 13 2022
Picture this: whoever gets the most votes wins.
How Alaska’s Election System Gives Voters More Choices
Apr 29 2022
This year, Alaska will debut a voting system that will give more Alaskans more choices at the ballot box.
4 Ways Ranked Choice Voting Would Fix America
May 20 2021
Ranked choice voting (RCV) is an electoral system where voters rank candidates from favorite to least favorite on the ballot. This way, if your top candidate does not win, your vote still counts toward your second preference.